DETERMINATION OF PLACE OF EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT UNDER INCOME TAX ACT, 1961

Introduction

The concept of Place of Effective Management [hereinafter “POEM”] is essential for determining the residency of a company for the purposes of Income Tax, which. The concept finds mention in Section 6(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (‘IT Act’) which provides that a company is deemed to be a resident in India in any previous year if i) it is an Indian Company[1] or if ii) its ‘Place of Effective Management is located within the country’ during the previous year[2].

The Explanation to Section 6(3) of the IT Act further provides the definition of POEM as under,

Explanation.— For the purposes of this clause “place of effective management” means a place where key management and commercial decisions that are necessary for the conduct of business of an entity as a whole are, in substance made.

Adding further granularity to this statutory framework, the Ministry of Finance has issued a circular on 24th January 2017 [3], elucidating the Guiding Principles for the determination of Place of Effective Management (POEM) of a Company.

This blog post seeks to provide succinct insights into the statutory provisions and guidelines, aiming to assist companies with global operations in navigating the intricacies of POEM for compliance and strategic decision-making.

Determination of Place of Effective Management

In establishing the POEM, the regulatory emphasizes on ‘Substance over Form’ [4]. This determination, analogous to residence, occurs on an annual basis. The crux lies in a company's engagement in 'Active Business Outside India,' reflecting the intent to recognize entities actively conducting significant operations beyond India.

§  Presumption of POEM Outside India: A key presumption of POEM outside India arises when a majority of board meetings are held outside the country during the fiscal year[5]. This determination is fact-specific, emphasizing the practical aspects of decision-making in tandem with the economic substance of a company's activities.

§  Impact of Board's Exercise of Powers: Notably, if the Board of Directors is observed to be relinquishing its managerial powers, with such powers exercised by the holding company in India, an executive committee or other individuals/entities resident in India, the Place of Effective Management will be deemed to be in India[6]. This provision aims to deter superficial relocation of board meetings without a substantive shift in management control.

§  Guiding Principles for Determining POEM: Three key principles guide the determination of POEM[7]:

o   Place of Management Decisions: Focus on where critical management decisions are made by the Board of Directors.

o   Location of Senior Management: Consider the location of senior management if the board has delegated authority, whether de-facto (by actions) or de-jure (by way of shareholder agreements).

o   Company's Head Office: Examine the location of the company's head office as a relevant factor. The ‘Head Office’ is typically considered to be the place where the company's senior management and their direct support staff are permanently or pre-dominantly located.

In essence, the evaluation of POEM necessitates a nuanced analysis of decision-making venues, board meeting locations, and the actual exercise of managerial powers. Ensuring alignment with the guiding principles is crucial for companies navigating the complexities of POEM determination. The subsequent section will delve into the presumption of POEM outside India concerning the concept of 'Active Business Outside India.'

Understanding Active Business Outside India

Central to determining a company's POEM is the criterion of 'Active Business Outside India.' This criterion, gauged against four key indicators, reflects the regulatory intent to recognize entities engaged substantially in active business operations beyond Indian borders.

Key Criteria for Active Business Outside India:

a.     Passive Income Less than 50%: Passive income includes transactions with associated enterprises or income from sources such as royalty, dividends, and capital gains. Income computation aligns with the laws of the country of incorporation. Passive income must be less than 50% of the total income.

b.     Less than 50% Assets in India: Asset computation follows the laws of the country of incorporation. Less than 50% of total assets should be situated in India.

c.      Less than 50% Employees in India: Employees encompass both directly employed personnel and those performing tasks similar to employees. Less than 50% of employees should be situated or resident in India.

d.     Payroll Expenses in India Less than 50%: Payroll expenses comprise salaries, wages, bonuses, and all other employee compensation and social costs. Payroll expenses incurred on employees in India should be less than 50% of the total payroll expenses.

Aligning with these criteria is essential for companies aspiring to establish a POEM outside India. Rigorous adherence to the laws of the country of incorporation in calculating income, assets, employees, and payroll expenses is imperative. Meeting these benchmarks ensures that the company is recognized as actively conducting business operations outside India, thereby contributing to a favorable POEM determination. The subsequent section will address housekeeping recommendations to fortify compliance and strategic alignment.

Guidance for Corporate Compliance

For corporations with offshore parent companies, managing POEM becomes a nuanced endeavour, especially when some employees and senior management are based in India, and revenue is generated within the country.

The following tailored housekeeping recommendations are essential for ensuring both compliance and strategic alignment:

a.     Strategic Management Decisions:

o   Carefully structure and strategically plan key management decisions to demonstrate effective decision-making outside India, in line with guiding principles.

o   Periodically assess the location of significant management decisions to align with business objectives and maintain POEM outside India.

 b.     Thorough Documentation and Record-Keeping:

o   Maintain meticulous documentation highlighting the decision-making process emphasizing the active involvement of offshore entities.

o   Establish a robust record-keeping system that evidences the offshore decision-making structure and involvement of senior management based outside India.

c.      Continuous Monitoring and Adaptation:

o   Conduct regular reviews to ensure adherence to the 'Active Business Outside India' criteria while recognizing the presence of employees and senior management in India.

o   Adapt strategies in response to changes in business dynamics, safeguarding against inadvertent shifts in POEM determinants.

Conclusion

In conclusion, corporations with offshore parent companies, employees, and revenue streams in India must navigate the POEM landscape judiciously. By actively managing decision structures, adhering to 'Active Business Outside India' criteria, and implementing robust documentation practices, these corporations can not only maintain compliance but also strategically position themselves for sustained success in the dynamic Indian regulatory environment. As the regulatory landscape evolves, continued vigilance and strategic planning will be essential for a seamless and effective POEM determination process.
————————————————————————————————————————————————————-

[1] Section 6(3)(i), Income Tax Act, 1961

[2] Section 6(3)(ii), Income Tax Act, 1961

[3] Circular No. 6 dated 24.01.2017

[4] Para 6, Circular No. 6 dated 24.01.2017

[5] Para 7, Circular No. 6 dated 24.01.2017

[6] Clause 8.2, Circular No. 6 dated 24.01.2017

[7] Clause 8.2, Circular No. 6 dated 24.01.2017